# bend-mathlib/list.bend: List lemmas (append, reverse, length, take, drop, map, fold, filter). import Base import ./nat.bend as MNat import ./bool.bend as MBool # The empty list is a right identity for append: xs ++ [] = xs. law append_nil: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.append(a, A, xs, Nil{}) == xs : List} def append_nil(a, A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %append_nil(a, A, t) : {h <> List.append(a, A, t, Nil{}) == h <> _ : List} {==} # The empty list is a left identity for append: [] ++ xs = xs. law nil_append: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -xs: List {List.append(a, A, Nil{}, xs) == xs : List} def nil_append(a, A, xs): {==} # Append is associative: (xs ++ ys) ++ zs = xs ++ (ys ++ zs). law append_assoc: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List for -zs: List {List.append(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), zs) == List.append(a, A, xs, List.append(a, A, ys, zs)) : List} def append_assoc(a, A, xs, ys, zs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %append_assoc(a, A, t, ys, zs) : {h <> List.append(a, A, List.append(a, A, t, ys), zs) == h <> _ : List} {==} # The length of an append is the sum of the lengths. law length_append: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List {List.length(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) == Nat.add(List.length(a, A, xs), List.length(a, A, ys)) : Nat} def length_append(a, A, xs, ys): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %length_append(a, A, t, ys) : {1n+List.length(a, A, List.append(a, A, t, ys)) == 1n+_ : Nat} {==} def internal_reverse_go_append(a, -A: Kind(a), xs: List, -ys: List, -acc: List) -> {List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, List.append(a, A, ys, acc)) == List.append(a, A, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, ys), acc) : List}: match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: internal_reverse_go_append(a, A, t, h <> ys, acc) # The reverse accumulator loop appends the reversed list to the accumulator. law reverse_go_spec: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -acc: List {List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, acc) == List.append(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs), acc) : List} def reverse_go_spec(a, A, xs, acc): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: internal_reverse_go_append(a, A, t, h <> Nil{}, acc) def internal_reverse_append_go(a, -A: Kind(a), xs: List, -ys: List, -acc: List) -> {List.reverse.go(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), acc) == List.reverse.go(a, A, ys, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, acc)) : List}: match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: internal_reverse_append_go(a, A, t, ys, h <> acc) # Reversing an append reverses and swaps the parts: reverse (xs ++ ys) = reverse ys ++ reverse xs. law reverse_append: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List {List.reverse(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) == List.append(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, ys), List.reverse(a, A, xs)) : List} def reverse_append(a, A, xs, ys): Equal.trans(List, List.reverse(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)), List.reverse.go(a, A, ys, List.reverse(a, A, xs)), List.append(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, ys), List.reverse(a, A, xs)), internal_reverse_append_go(a, A, xs, ys, Nil{}), reverse_go_spec(a, A, ys, List.reverse(a, A, xs))) def internal_reverse_go_go(a, -A: Kind(a), xs: List, -acc: List) -> {List.reverse.go(a, A, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, acc), Nil{}) == List.reverse.go(a, A, acc, xs) : List}: match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: internal_reverse_go_go(a, A, t, h <> acc) # Reversing twice gives the list back. law reverse_reverse: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.reverse(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) == xs : List} def reverse_reverse(a, A, xs): internal_reverse_go_go(a, A, xs, Nil{}) def internal_length_reverse_go(a, -A: Kind(a), xs: List, -acc: List, +n: Nat, e: {List.length(a, A, acc) == n : Nat}) -> {List.length(a, A, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, acc)) == Nat.add(n, List.length(a, A, xs)) : Nat}: match xs: case Nil{}: %Equal.sym(Nat, Nat.add(n, 0n), n, MNat.add_zero(n)) : {List.length(a, A, acc) == _ : Nat} e case h <> t: %Equal.sym(Nat, Nat.add(n, 1n+List.length(a, A, t)), 1n+Nat.add(n, List.length(a, A, t)), MNat.add_succ(n, List.length(a, A, t))) : {List.length(a, A, List.reverse.go(a, A, t, h <> acc)) == _ : Nat} internal_length_reverse_go(a, A, t, h <> acc, 1n+n, Equal.cong(Nat, Nat, k => 1n+k, List.length(a, A, acc), n, e)) # Reversing preserves the length. law length_reverse: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.length(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) == List.length(a, A, xs) : Nat} def length_reverse(a, A, xs): internal_length_reverse_go(a, A, xs, Nil{}, 0n, {==}) # A right fold over an append folds the first part onto the fold of the second. law foldr_append: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B -> B for xs: List for -ys: List for -z: B {List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), z) == List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, ys, z)) : B} def foldr_append(a, A, B, f, xs, ys, z): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %foldr_append(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, t, ys, z) : {f(h, List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.append(a, A, t, ys), z)) == f(h, _) : B} {==} # Taking n elements and appending the rest after dropping n gives the list back. law take_append_drop: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat {List.append(a, A, List.take(a, A, xs, n), List.drop(a, A, xs, n)) == xs : List} def take_append_drop(a, A, xs, n): match xs n: case Nil{} _: {==} case h <> t 0n: {==} case h <> t 1n+p: %take_append_drop(a, A, t, p) : {h <> List.append(a, A, List.take(a, A, t, p), List.drop(a, A, t, p)) == h <> _ : List} {==} # Mapping preserves the length. law length_map: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List {List.length(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) == List.length(&1, A, xs) : Nat} def length_map(A, B, f, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %length_map(~A, ~B, ~f, t) : {1n+List.length(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, t)) == 1n+_ : Nat} {==} # Mapping over an append maps each part: map f (xs ++ ys) = map f xs ++ map f ys. law map_append: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List for -ys: List {List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.append(&1, A, xs, ys)) == List.append(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, ys)) : List} def map_append(A, B, f, xs, ys): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %map_append(~A, ~B, ~f, t, ys) : {f(h) <> List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.append(&1, A, t, ys)) == f(h) <> _ : List} {==} # Mapping twice is mapping the composition: map g (map f xs) = map (g . f) xs. law map_map: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~C: Type for ~f: A -> B for ~g: B -> C for xs: List {List.map(~B, ~C, ~g, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) == List.map(~A, ~C, ~(x => g(f(x))), xs) : List} def map_map(A, B, C, f, g, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %map_map(~A, ~B, ~C, ~f, ~g, t) : {g(f(h)) <> List.map(~B, ~C, ~g, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, t)) == g(f(h)) <> _ : List} {==} # Taking zero elements gives the empty list. law take_zero: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.take(a, A, xs, 0n) == Nil{} : List} def take_zero(a, A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: {==} # Dropping zero elements gives the list back. law drop_zero: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.drop(a, A, xs, 0n) == xs : List} def drop_zero(a, A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: {==} # Taking from the empty list gives the empty list. law take_nil: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -n: Nat {List.take(a, A, Nil{}, n) == Nil{} : List} def take_nil(a, A, n): {==} # Dropping from the empty list gives the empty list. law drop_nil: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -n: Nat {List.drop(a, A, Nil{}, n) == Nil{} : List} def drop_nil(a, A, n): {==} # Taking n elements leaves min(n, length) of them. law length_take: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat {List.length(a, A, List.take(a, A, xs, n)) == Nat.min(n, List.length(a, A, xs)) : Nat} def length_take(a, A, xs, n): match xs n: case Nil{} _: Equal.sym(Nat, Nat.min(n, 0n), 0n, MNat.min_zero(n)) case h <> t 0n: {==} case h <> t 1n+p: %length_take(a, A, t, p) : {1n+List.length(a, A, List.take(a, A, t, p)) == 1n+_ : Nat} {==} # Dropping n elements leaves length - n of them. law length_drop: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat {List.length(a, A, List.drop(a, A, xs, n)) == Nat.sub(List.length(a, A, xs), n) : Nat} def length_drop(a, A, xs, n): match xs n: case Nil{} _: Equal.sym(Nat, Nat.sub(0n, n), 0n, MNat.zero_sub(n)) case h <> t 0n: {==} case h <> t 1n+p: length_drop(a, A, t, p) # Taking as many elements as the list has gives the list back. law take_length: for -A: Data for +xs: List<&2, A> {List.take(&2, A, xs, List.length(&2, A, xs)) == xs : List<&2, A>} def take_length(A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %take_length(A, t) : {h <> List.take(&2, A, t, List.length(&2, A, t)) == h <> _ : List<&2, A>} {==} # Dropping as many elements as the list has gives the empty list. law drop_length: for -A: Data for +xs: List<&2, A> {List.drop(&2, A, xs, List.length(&2, A, xs)) == Nil{} : List<&2, A>} def drop_length(A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: drop_length(A, t) # Taking m from the first n is taking min(n, m). law take_take: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat for m: Nat {List.take(a, A, List.take(a, A, xs, n), m) == List.take(a, A, xs, Nat.min(n, m)) : List} def take_take(a, A, xs, n, m): match xs n m: case Nil{} _ _: {==} case h <> t 0n _: {==} case h <> t 1n+p 0n: {==} case h <> t 1n+p 1n+q: %take_take(a, A, t, p, q) : {h <> List.take(a, A, List.take(a, A, t, p), q) == h <> _ : List} {==} # Dropping m after dropping n is dropping n + m. law drop_drop: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat for -m: Nat {List.drop(a, A, List.drop(a, A, xs, n), m) == List.drop(a, A, xs, Nat.add(n, m)) : List} def drop_drop(a, A, xs, n, m): match xs n m: case Nil{} _ _: {==} case h <> t 0n _: {==} case h <> t 1n+p _: drop_drop(a, A, t, p, m) # Reversing the empty list gives the empty list. law reverse_nil: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) {List.reverse(a, A, Nil{}) == Nil{} : List} def reverse_nil(a, A): {==} # Reversing a one-element list gives it back. law reverse_singleton: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A {List.reverse(a, A, [x]) == [x] : List} def reverse_singleton(a, A, x): {==} # Replicating x n times gives a list of length n. law length_replicate: for -A: Data for n: Nat for -x: A {List.length(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x)) == n : Nat} def length_replicate(A, n, x): match n: case 0n: {==} case 1n+p: %length_replicate(A, p, x) : {1n+List.length(&2, A, List.replicate(A, p, x)) == 1n+_ : Nat} {==} def internal_length_range_go(+n: Nat, acc: List<&2, Nat>) -> {List.length(&2, Nat, List.range.go(n, acc)) == Nat.add(n, List.length(&2, Nat, acc)) : Nat}: match n: case 0n: {==} case 1n+p: %MNat.add_succ(p, List.length(&2, Nat, acc)) : {List.length(&2, Nat, List.range.go(p, p <> acc)) == _ : Nat} internal_length_range_go(p, p <> acc) # Range(n) has length n. law length_range: for n: Nat {List.length(&2, Nat, List.range(n)) == n : Nat} def length_range(n): +n = n %Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(&2, Nat, List.range.go(n, Nil{})), Nat.add(n, 0n), internal_length_range_go(n, Nil{})) : {_ == n : Nat} MNat.add_zero(n) # Zipping two lists gives the length of the shorter one. law length_zip: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List {List.length(&1, A & A, List.zip(a, A, a, A, xs, ys)) == Nat.min(List.length(a, A, xs), List.length(a, A, ys)) : Nat} def length_zip(a, A, xs, ys): match xs ys: case Nil{} _: {==} case h <> t Nil{}: {==} case h <> t y <> yt: %length_zip(a, A, t, yt) : {1n+List.length(&1, A & A, List.zip(a, A, a, A, t, yt)) == 1n+_ : Nat} {==} # Appending after a cons: (x :: xs) ++ ys = x :: (xs ++ ys). law append_cons: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List for -ys: List {List.append(a, A, x <> xs, ys) == x <> List.append(a, A, xs, ys) : List} def append_cons(a, A, x, xs, ys): {==} # The empty list has length zero. law length_nil: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) {List.length(a, A, Nil{}) == 0n : Nat} def length_nil(a, A): {==} # A cons is one longer than its tail. law length_cons: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List {List.length(a, A, x <> xs) == 1n+List.length(a, A, xs) : Nat} def length_cons(a, A, x, xs): {==} # Concatenating an append concatenates each part: concat (xss ++ yss) = concat xss ++ concat yss. law concat_append: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xss: List> for -yss: List> {List.concat(a, A, List.append(a, List, xss, yss)) == List.append(a, A, List.concat(a, A, xss), List.concat(a, A, yss)) : List} def concat_append(a, A, xss, yss): match xss: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %Equal.sym(List, List.concat(a, A, List.append(a, List, t, yss)), List.append(a, A, List.concat(a, A, t), List.concat(a, A, yss)), concat_append(a, A, t, yss)) : {List.append(a, A, h, _) == List.append(a, A, List.append(a, A, h, List.concat(a, A, t)), List.concat(a, A, yss)) : List} Equal.sym(List, List.append(a, A, List.append(a, A, h, List.concat(a, A, t)), List.concat(a, A, yss)), List.append(a, A, h, List.append(a, A, List.concat(a, A, t), List.concat(a, A, yss))), append_assoc(a, A, h, List.concat(a, A, t), List.concat(a, A, yss))) # A left fold over an append folds the second part from the fold of the first. law foldl_append: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~B: Type for ~f: B -> A -> B for xs: List for -ys: List for -z: B {List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), z) == List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, ys, List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, z)) : B} def foldl_append(a, A, B, f, xs, ys, z): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: foldl_append(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, t, ys, f(z, h)) def internal_map_reverse_go(~A: Type, ~B: Type, ~f: A -> B, xs: List, acc: List) -> {List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse.go(&1, A, xs, acc)) == List.reverse.go(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, acc)) : List}: match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: internal_map_reverse_go(~A, ~B, ~f, t, h <> acc) # Mapping commutes with reversing: map f (reverse xs) = reverse (map f xs). law map_reverse: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List {List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse(&1, A, xs)) == List.reverse(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) : List} def map_reverse(A, B, f, xs): internal_map_reverse_go(~A, ~B, ~f, xs, Nil{}) # All over an append is all over each part, joined by and. law all_append: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List for -ys: List {List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) == Bool.and(List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, xs), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)) : Bool} def all_append(a, A, f, xs, ys): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %Equal.sym(Bool, List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, List.append(a, A, t, ys)), Bool.and(List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, t), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)), all_append(~a, ~A, ~f, t, ys)) : {Bool.and(f(h), _) == Bool.and(Bool.and(f(h), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, t)), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)) : Bool} Equal.sym(Bool, Bool.and(Bool.and(f(h), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, t)), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)), Bool.and(f(h), Bool.and(List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, t), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, ys))), MBool.and_assoc(f(h), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, t), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, ys))) # Any over an append is any over each part, joined by or. law any_append: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List for -ys: List {List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) == Bool.or(List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, xs), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)) : Bool} def any_append(a, A, f, xs, ys): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %Equal.sym(Bool, List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, List.append(a, A, t, ys)), Bool.or(List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, t), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)), any_append(~a, ~A, ~f, t, ys)) : {Bool.or(f(h), _) == Bool.or(Bool.or(f(h), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, t)), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)) : Bool} Equal.sym(Bool, Bool.or(Bool.or(f(h), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, t)), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)), Bool.or(f(h), Bool.or(List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, t), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, ys))), MBool.or_assoc(f(h), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, t), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, ys))) def internal_filter_put_append(-A: Data, h: A, r: List<&2, A>, s: List<&2, A>, b: Bool) -> {List.append(&2, A, List.filter.put(A, h, r, b), s) == List.filter.put(A, h, List.append(&2, A, r, s), b) : List<&2, A>}: match b: case False{}: {==} case True{}: {==} # Filtering an append filters each part. law filter_append: for ~A: Data for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> for ys: List<&2, A> {List.filter(~A, ~f, List.append(&2, A, xs, ys)) == List.append(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, xs), List.filter(~A, ~f, ys)) : List<&2, A>} def filter_append(A, f, xs, ys): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case +h <> t: +ys = ys +t = t %Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.filter(~A, ~f, List.append(&2, A, t, ys)), List.append(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, t), List.filter(~A, ~f, ys)), filter_append(~A, ~f, t, ys)) : {List.filter.put(A, h, _, f(h)) == List.append(&2, A, List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~f, t), f(h)), List.filter(~A, ~f, ys)) : List<&2, A>} Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.append(&2, A, List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~f, t), f(h)), List.filter(~A, ~f, ys)), List.filter.put(A, h, List.append(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, t), List.filter(~A, ~f, ys)), f(h)), internal_filter_put_append(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~f, t), List.filter(~A, ~f, ys), f(h))) # An append contains x iff either part does. law contains_append: for ~A: Data for ~eq: A -> A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> for -ys: List<&2, A> for +x: A {List.contains(~A, ~eq, List.append(&2, A, xs, ys), x) == Bool.or(List.contains(~A, ~eq, xs, x), List.contains(~A, ~eq, ys, x)) : Bool} def contains_append(A, eq, xs, ys, x): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %Equal.sym(Bool, List.contains(~A, ~eq, List.append(&2, A, t, ys), x), Bool.or(List.contains(~A, ~eq, t, x), List.contains(~A, ~eq, ys, x)), contains_append(~A, ~eq, t, ys, x)) : {Bool.or(eq(h, x), _) == Bool.or(Bool.or(eq(h, x), List.contains(~A, ~eq, t, x)), List.contains(~A, ~eq, ys, x)) : Bool} Equal.sym(Bool, Bool.or(Bool.or(eq(h, x), List.contains(~A, ~eq, t, x)), List.contains(~A, ~eq, ys, x)), Bool.or(eq(h, x), Bool.or(List.contains(~A, ~eq, t, x), List.contains(~A, ~eq, ys, x))), MBool.or_assoc(eq(h, x), List.contains(~A, ~eq, t, x), List.contains(~A, ~eq, ys, x))) def internal_length_filter_put_le(-A: Data, h: A, r: List<&2, A>, b: Bool) -> {Nat.is_le(List.length(&2, A, List.filter.put(A, h, r, b)), 1n+List.length(&2, A, r)) == True{} : Bool}: match b: case False{}: MNat.le_succ(List.length(&2, A, r)) case True{}: MNat.le_refl(1n+List.length(&2, A, r)) # Filtering never makes a list longer. law length_filter_le: for ~A: Data for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> {Nat.is_le(List.length(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, xs)), List.length(&2, A, xs)) == True{} : Bool} def length_filter_le(A, f, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case +h <> t: +t = t MNat.le_trans(List.length(&2, A, List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~f, t), f(h))), 1n+List.length(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, t)), 1n+List.length(&2, A, t), internal_length_filter_put_le(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~f, t), f(h)), MNat.succ_le_succ(List.length(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, t)), List.length(&2, A, t), length_filter_le(~A, ~f, t))) # Membership in a list, as a reusable proposition. def mem(~A: Data, ~eq: A -> A -> Bool, +x: A, xs: List<&2, A>) -> Data: {List.contains(~A, ~eq, xs, x) == True{} : Bool} # A list is sorted by a comparator when every adjacent pair is in order. def sorted_by(~A: Data, ~le: A -> A -> Bool, +xs: List<&2, A>) -> Data: {List.all(~&1, ~(A & A), ~(p => le(Pair.fst(A, A, p), Pair.snd(A, A, p))), List.zip(&2, A, &2, A, xs, List.tail(&2, A, xs))) == True{} : Bool} def internal_or_of_right(a: Bool, -b: Bool, hb: {b == True{} : Bool}) -> {Bool.or(a, b) == True{} : Bool}: match a: case False{}: hb case True{}: {==} def internal_or_of_or(a: Bool, -b: Bool, -c: Bool, h: {Bool.or(a, b) == True{} : Bool}, k: {b == True{} : Bool} -> {c == True{} : Bool}) -> {Bool.or(a, c) == True{} : Bool}: match a: case False{}: k(h) case True{}: {==} def internal_and_left(a: Bool, -b: Bool, h: {Bool.and(a, b) == True{} : Bool}) -> {a == True{} : Bool}: match a: case False{}: Empty.absurd({False{} == True{} : Bool}, MNat.internal_false_ne_true(h)) case True{}: {==} def internal_and_right(a: Bool, -b: Bool, h: {Bool.and(a, b) == True{} : Bool}) -> {b == True{} : Bool}: match a: case False{}: Empty.absurd({b == True{} : Bool}, MNat.internal_false_ne_true(h)) case True{}: h def internal_mem_append_left(+xs: List<&2, Nat>, +ys: List<&2, Nat>, +x: Nat, h: {List.contains(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, xs, x) == True{} : Bool}) -> {List.contains(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, List.append(&2, Nat, xs, ys), x) == True{} : Bool}: match xs: case Nil{}: Empty.absurd({List.contains(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, ys, x) == True{} : Bool}, MNat.internal_false_ne_true(h)) case hd <> tl: internal_or_of_or(Nat.is_eq(hd, x), List.contains(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, tl, x), List.contains(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, List.append(&2, Nat, tl, ys), x), h, internal_mem_append_left(tl, ys, x)) def internal_mem_append_right(+xs: List<&2, Nat>, +ys: List<&2, Nat>, +x: Nat, h: {List.contains(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, ys, x) == True{} : Bool}) -> {List.contains(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, List.append(&2, Nat, xs, ys), x) == True{} : Bool}: match xs: case Nil{}: h case hd <> tl: internal_or_of_right(Nat.is_eq(hd, x), List.contains(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, List.append(&2, Nat, tl, ys), x), internal_mem_append_right(tl, ys, x, h)) # The head of a Nat list is a member of it (membership by Nat.is_eq). law mem_cons_self: for x: Nat for -xs: List<&2, Nat> mem(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, x, x <> xs) def mem_cons_self(x, xs): %Equal.sym(Bool, Nat.is_eq(x, x), True{}, MNat.is_eq_refl(x)) : {Bool.or(_, List.contains(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, xs, x)) == True{} : Bool} {==} # A member of a Nat list stays a member when a head is prepended. law mem_cons_of_mem: for x: Nat for y: Nat for -xs: List<&2, Nat> for h: mem(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, x, xs) mem(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, x, y <> xs) def mem_cons_of_mem(x, y, xs, h): +x = x internal_or_of_right(Nat.is_eq(y, x), List.contains(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, xs, x), h) # No Nat is a member of the empty list. law not_mem_nil: for -x: Nat mem(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, x, Nil{}) -> Empty def not_mem_nil(x, h): MNat.internal_false_ne_true(h) # A member of xs is a member of xs ++ ys (Nat lists). law mem_append_left: for xs: List<&2, Nat> for ys: List<&2, Nat> for x: Nat for h: mem(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, x, xs) mem(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, x, List.append(&2, Nat, xs, ys)) def mem_append_left(xs, ys, x, h): internal_mem_append_left(xs, ys, x, h) # A member of ys is a member of xs ++ ys (Nat lists). law mem_append_right: for xs: List<&2, Nat> for ys: List<&2, Nat> for x: Nat for h: mem(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, x, ys) mem(~Nat, ~Nat.is_eq, x, List.append(&2, Nat, xs, ys)) def mem_append_right(xs, ys, x, h): internal_mem_append_right(xs, ys, x, h) # The empty Nat list is sorted by Nat.is_le. law sorted_nil: sorted_by(~Nat, ~Nat.is_le, Nil{}) def sorted_nil(): {==} # A one-element Nat list is sorted by Nat.is_le. law sorted_single: for -x: Nat sorted_by(~Nat, ~Nat.is_le, [x]) def sorted_single(x): {==} # A Nat list sorted by Nat.is_le stays sorted under a head that is <= the next element. law sorted_cons_cons_intro: for -x: Nat for -y: Nat for -t: List<&2, Nat> for hxy: MNat.le(x, y) for hyt: sorted_by(~Nat, ~Nat.is_le, y <> t) sorted_by(~Nat, ~Nat.is_le, x <> y <> t) def sorted_cons_cons_intro(x, y, t, hxy, hyt): %Equal.sym(Bool, Nat.is_le(x, y), True{}, hxy) : {Bool.and(_, List.all(~&1, ~(Nat & Nat), ~(p => Nat.is_le(Pair.fst(Nat, Nat, p), Pair.snd(Nat, Nat, p))), List.zip(&2, Nat, &2, Nat, y <> t, t))) == True{} : Bool} hyt # The first two elements of a Nat list sorted by Nat.is_le are in order. law sorted_cons_cons_elim_le: for x: Nat for y: Nat for -t: List<&2, Nat> for h: sorted_by(~Nat, ~Nat.is_le, x <> y <> t) MNat.le(x, y) def sorted_cons_cons_elim_le(x, y, t, h): internal_and_left(Nat.is_le(x, y), List.all(~&1, ~(Nat & Nat), ~(p => Nat.is_le(Pair.fst(Nat, Nat, p), Pair.snd(Nat, Nat, p))), List.zip(&2, Nat, &2, Nat, y <> t, t)), h) # The tail of a Nat list of two or more elements sorted by Nat.is_le is sorted. law sorted_cons_cons_elim_tail: for x: Nat for y: Nat for -t: List<&2, Nat> for h: sorted_by(~Nat, ~Nat.is_le, x <> y <> t) sorted_by(~Nat, ~Nat.is_le, y <> t) def sorted_cons_cons_elim_tail(x, y, t, h): internal_and_right(Nat.is_le(x, y), List.all(~&1, ~(Nat & Nat), ~(p => Nat.is_le(Pair.fst(Nat, Nat, p), Pair.snd(Nat, Nat, p))), List.zip(&2, Nat, &2, Nat, y <> t, t)), h) # The tail of a nonempty Nat list sorted by Nat.is_le is sorted. law sorted_tail: for x: Nat for xs: List<&2, Nat> for h: sorted_by(~Nat, ~Nat.is_le, x <> xs) sorted_by(~Nat, ~Nat.is_le, xs) def sorted_tail(x, xs, h): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case y <> t: internal_and_right(Nat.is_le(x, y), List.all(~&1, ~(Nat & Nat), ~(p => Nat.is_le(Pair.fst(Nat, Nat, p), Pair.snd(Nat, Nat, p))), List.zip(&2, Nat, &2, Nat, y <> t, t)), h) # Taking the length of the first part of an append gives the first part back. law take_left: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List {List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), List.length(a, A, xs)) == xs : List} def take_left(a, A, xs, ys): match xs: case Nil{}: take_zero(a, A, ys) case h <> t: %take_left(a, A, t, ys) : {h <> List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, t, ys), List.length(a, A, t)) == h <> _ : List} {==} # Dropping the length of the first part of an append gives the second part. law drop_left: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List {List.drop(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), List.length(a, A, xs)) == ys : List} def drop_left(a, A, xs, ys): match xs: case Nil{}: drop_zero(a, A, ys) case h <> t: drop_left(a, A, t, ys) # Taking past the first part of an append keeps it and takes the rest from the second part. law take_append: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List for -n: Nat {List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), Nat.add(List.length(a, A, xs), n)) == List.append(a, A, xs, List.take(a, A, ys, n)) : List} def take_append(a, A, xs, ys, n): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %take_append(a, A, t, ys, n) : {h <> List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, t, ys), Nat.add(List.length(a, A, t), n)) == h <> _ : List} {==} # Dropping past the first part of an append drops the rest from the second part. law drop_append: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List for -n: Nat {List.drop(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), Nat.add(List.length(a, A, xs), n)) == List.drop(a, A, ys, n) : List} def drop_append(a, A, xs, ys, n): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: drop_append(a, A, t, ys, n) # Taking at most the length of the first part of an append only sees the first part. law take_append_of_le_length: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List for n: Nat for h: MNat.le(n, List.length(a, A, xs)) {List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), n) == List.take(a, A, xs, n) : List} def take_append_of_le_length(a, A, xs, ys, n, h): match xs n: case Nil{} 0n: take_zero(a, A, ys) case Nil{} 1n+p: Empty.absurd({List.take(a, A, ys, 1n+p) == Nil{} : List}, MNat.internal_false_ne_true(h)) case x <> t 0n: {==} case x <> t 1n+p: %take_append_of_le_length(a, A, t, ys, p, h) : {x <> List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, t, ys), p) == x <> _ : List} {==} # Dropping at most the length of the first part of an append drops only from the first part. law drop_append_of_le_length: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List for n: Nat for h: MNat.le(n, List.length(a, A, xs)) {List.drop(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), n) == List.append(a, A, List.drop(a, A, xs, n), ys) : List} def drop_append_of_le_length(a, A, xs, ys, n, h): match xs n: case Nil{} 0n: drop_zero(a, A, ys) case Nil{} 1n+p: Empty.absurd({List.drop(a, A, ys, 1n+p) == ys : List}, MNat.internal_false_ne_true(h)) case x <> t 0n: {==} case x <> t 1n+p: drop_append_of_le_length(a, A, t, ys, p, h) # Mapping commutes with taking: map f (take n xs) = take n (map f xs). law map_take: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List for n: Nat {List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.take(&1, A, xs, n)) == List.take(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), n) : List} def map_take(A, B, f, xs, n): match xs n: case Nil{} _: {==} case h <> t 0n: {==} case h <> t 1n+p: %map_take(~A, ~B, ~f, t, p) : {f(h) <> List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.take(&1, A, t, p)) == f(h) <> _ : List} {==} # Mapping commutes with dropping: map f (drop n xs) = drop n (map f xs). law map_drop: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List for n: Nat {List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.drop(&1, A, xs, n)) == List.drop(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), n) : List} def map_drop(A, B, f, xs, n): match xs n: case Nil{} _: {==} case h <> t 0n: {==} case h <> t 1n+p: map_drop(~A, ~B, ~f, t, p) # Taking m from n copies of x gives min(m, n) copies of x. law take_replicate: for -A: Data for n: Nat for m: Nat for -x: A {List.take(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), m) == List.replicate(A, Nat.min(m, n), x) : List<&2, A>} def take_replicate(A, n, m, x): match n m: case 0n _: %MNat.min_zero_sym(m) : {Nil{} == List.replicate(A, _, x) : List<&2, A>} {==} case 1n+p 0n: {==} case 1n+p 1n+q: %take_replicate(A, p, q, x) : {x <> List.take(&2, A, List.replicate(A, p, x), q) == x <> _ : List<&2, A>} {==} # Dropping m from n copies of x gives n - m copies of x. law drop_replicate: for -A: Data for n: Nat for m: Nat for -x: A {List.drop(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), m) == List.replicate(A, Nat.sub(n, m), x) : List<&2, A>} def drop_replicate(A, n, m, x): match n m: case 0n _: {==} case 1n+p 0n: {==} case 1n+p 1n+q: drop_replicate(A, p, q, x) # Taking n elements gives at most n of them. law length_take_le: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat MNat.le(List.length(a, A, List.take(a, A, xs, n)), n) def length_take_le(a, A, xs, n): match xs n: case Nil{} _: MNat.zero_le(n) case h <> t 0n: {==} case h <> t 1n+p: MNat.succ_le_succ(List.length(a, A, List.take(a, A, t, p)), p, length_take_le(a, A, t, p)) # The tail is one shorter than the list, or empty: length (tail xs) = length xs - 1. law length_tail: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.length(a, A, List.tail(a, A, xs)) == Nat.sub(List.length(a, A, xs), 1n) : Nat} def length_tail(a, A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: MNat.sub_zero_sym(List.length(a, A, t)) # Mapping the identity gives the list back. law map_id: for ~A: Type for xs: List {List.map(~A, ~A, ~(x => x), xs) == xs : List} def map_id(A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %map_id(~A, t) : {h <> List.map(~A, ~A, ~(x => x), t) == h <> _ : List} {==} # A right fold over a map folds with the mapped function: foldr g z (map f xs) = foldr (g . f) z xs. law foldr_map: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~C: Type for ~f: A -> B for ~g: B -> C -> C for xs: List for -z: C {List.foldr(~&1, ~B, ~C, ~g, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), z) == List.foldr(~&1, ~A, ~C, ~(x => y => g(f(x), y)), xs, z) : C} def foldr_map(A, B, C, f, g, xs, z): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %foldr_map(~A, ~B, ~C, ~f, ~g, t, z) : {g(f(h), List.foldr(~&1, ~B, ~C, ~g, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, t), z)) == g(f(h), _) : C} {==} # A left fold over a map folds with the mapped function: foldl g z (map f xs) = foldl (fun acc x => g acc (f x)) z xs. law foldl_map: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~C: Type for ~f: A -> B for ~g: C -> B -> C for xs: List for -z: C {List.foldl(~&1, ~B, ~C, ~g, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), z) == List.foldl(~&1, ~A, ~C, ~(x => y => g(x, f(y))), xs, z) : C} def foldl_map(A, B, C, f, g, xs, z): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: foldl_map(~A, ~B, ~C, ~f, ~g, t, g(z, f(h))) # Replicating m + n times appends m copies to n copies. law replicate_add: for -A: Data for m: Nat for -n: Nat for -x: A {List.replicate(A, Nat.add(m, n), x) == List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, m, x), List.replicate(A, n, x)) : List<&2, A>} def replicate_add(A, m, n, x): match m: case 0n: {==} case 1n+p: %replicate_add(A, p, n, x) : {x <> List.replicate(A, Nat.add(p, n), x) == x <> _ : List<&2, A>} {==} def internal_replicate_append_nil(-A: Data, n: Nat, -x: A) -> {List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), Nil{}) == List.replicate(A, n, x) : List<&2, A>}: match n: case 0n: {==} case 1n+p: %internal_replicate_append_nil(A, p, x) : {x <> List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, p, x), Nil{}) == x <> _ : List<&2, A>} {==} def internal_replicate_append_cons(-A: Data, n: Nat, -x: A, -acc: List<&2, A>) -> {List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), x <> acc) == x <> List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), acc) : List<&2, A>}: match n: case 0n: {==} case 1n+p: %internal_replicate_append_cons(A, p, x, acc) : {x <> List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, p, x), x <> acc) == x <> _ : List<&2, A>} {==} def internal_reverse_go_replicate(-A: Data, n: Nat, -x: A, -acc: List<&2, A>) -> {List.reverse.go(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), acc) == List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), acc) : List<&2, A>}: match n: case 0n: {==} case 1n+p: +p = p Equal.trans(List<&2, A>, List.reverse.go(&2, A, List.replicate(A, p, x), x <> acc), List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, p, x), x <> acc), x <> List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, p, x), acc), internal_reverse_go_replicate(A, p, x, x <> acc), internal_replicate_append_cons(A, p, x, acc)) # Reversing n copies of x gives them back. law reverse_replicate: for -A: Data for n: Nat for -x: A {List.reverse(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x)) == List.replicate(A, n, x) : List<&2, A>} def reverse_replicate(A, n, x): +n = n Equal.trans(List<&2, A>, List.reverse(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x)), List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), Nil{}), List.replicate(A, n, x), internal_reverse_go_replicate(A, n, x, Nil{}), internal_replicate_append_nil(A, n, x)) # Filtering with an always-true predicate gives the list back. law filter_true: for ~A: Data for xs: List<&2, A> {List.filter(~A, ~(x => True{}), xs) == xs : List<&2, A>} def filter_true(A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %filter_true(~A, t) : {h <> List.filter(~A, ~(x => True{}), t) == h <> _ : List<&2, A>} {==} # Filtering with an always-false predicate gives the empty list. law filter_false: for ~A: Data for xs: List<&2, A> {List.filter(~A, ~(x => False{}), xs) == Nil{} : List<&2, A>} def filter_false(A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: filter_false(~A, t) def internal_filter_put_filter(~A: Data, ~p: A -> Bool, +h: A, r: List<&2, A>, b: Bool) -> {List.filter(~A, ~p, List.filter.put(A, h, r, b)) == List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~p, r), Bool.and(p(h), b)) : List<&2, A>}: match b: case False{}: %MBool.and_false_sym(p(h)) : {List.filter(~A, ~p, r) == List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~p, r), _) : List<&2, A>} {==} case True{}: %MBool.and_true_sym(p(h)) : {List.filter(~A, ~p, h <> r) == List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~p, r), _) : List<&2, A>} {==} # Filtering twice is filtering by both predicates: filter p (filter q xs) = filter (p and q) xs. law filter_filter: for ~A: Data for ~p: A -> Bool for ~q: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> {List.filter(~A, ~p, List.filter(~A, ~q, xs)) == List.filter(~A, ~(+x => Bool.and(p(x), q(x))), xs) : List<&2, A>} def filter_filter(A, p, q, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case +h <> t: +t = t %filter_filter(~A, ~p, ~q, t) : {List.filter(~A, ~p, List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~q, t), q(h))) == List.filter.put(A, h, _, Bool.and(p(h), q(h))) : List<&2, A>} internal_filter_put_filter(~A, ~p, h, List.filter(~A, ~q, t), q(h)) def internal_all_filter_put(~A: Data, ~q: A -> Bool, -h: A, r: List<&2, A>, b: Bool) -> {List.all(~&2, ~A, ~q, List.filter.put(A, h, r, b)) == Bool.and(Bool.or(Bool.not(b), q(h)), List.all(~&2, ~A, ~q, r)) : Bool}: match b: case False{}: {==} case True{}: {==} # All over a filter checks q only where p holds: all q (filter p xs) = all (not p or q) xs. law all_filter: for ~A: Data for ~p: A -> Bool for ~q: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> {List.all(~&2, ~A, ~q, List.filter(~A, ~p, xs)) == List.all(~&2, ~A, ~(+x => Bool.or(Bool.not(p(x)), q(x))), xs) : Bool} def all_filter(A, p, q, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case +h <> t: +t = t %all_filter(~A, ~p, ~q, t) : {List.all(~&2, ~A, ~q, List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~p, t), p(h))) == Bool.and(Bool.or(Bool.not(p(h)), q(h)), _) : Bool} internal_all_filter_put(~A, ~q, h, List.filter(~A, ~p, t), p(h)) def internal_any_filter_put(~A: Data, ~q: A -> Bool, -h: A, r: List<&2, A>, b: Bool) -> {List.any(~&2, ~A, ~q, List.filter.put(A, h, r, b)) == Bool.or(Bool.and(b, q(h)), List.any(~&2, ~A, ~q, r)) : Bool}: match b: case False{}: {==} case True{}: {==} # Any over a filter looks for q only where p holds: any q (filter p xs) = any (p and q) xs. law any_filter: for ~A: Data for ~p: A -> Bool for ~q: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> {List.any(~&2, ~A, ~q, List.filter(~A, ~p, xs)) == List.any(~&2, ~A, ~(+x => Bool.and(p(x), q(x))), xs) : Bool} def any_filter(A, p, q, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case +h <> t: +t = t %any_filter(~A, ~p, ~q, t) : {List.any(~&2, ~A, ~q, List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~p, t), p(h))) == Bool.or(Bool.and(p(h), q(h)), _) : Bool} internal_any_filter_put(~A, ~q, h, List.filter(~A, ~p, t), p(h)) # All over a map checks the composed predicate: all p (map f xs) = all (p . f) xs. law all_map: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for ~p: B -> Bool for xs: List {List.all(~&1, ~B, ~p, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) == List.all(~&1, ~A, ~(x => p(f(x))), xs) : Bool} def all_map(A, B, f, p, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %all_map(~A, ~B, ~f, ~p, t) : {Bool.and(p(f(h)), List.all(~&1, ~B, ~p, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, t))) == Bool.and(p(f(h)), _) : Bool} {==} # Any over a map checks the composed predicate: any p (map f xs) = any (p . f) xs. law any_map: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for ~p: B -> Bool for xs: List {List.any(~&1, ~B, ~p, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) == List.any(~&1, ~A, ~(x => p(f(x))), xs) : Bool} def any_map(A, B, f, p, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %any_map(~A, ~B, ~f, ~p, t) : {Bool.or(p(f(h)), List.any(~&1, ~B, ~p, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, t))) == Bool.or(p(f(h)), _) : Bool} {==} def internal_all_reverse_go(~a: Quant, ~A: Kind(a), ~f: A -> Bool, xs: List, -acc: List, c: Bool, e: {List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, acc) == c : Bool}) -> {List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, acc)) == Bool.and(c, List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, xs)) : Bool}: match xs c: case Nil{} True{}: e case Nil{} False{}: e case h <> t True{}: +v = f(h) internal_all_reverse_go(~a, ~A, ~f, t, h <> acc, v, Equal.trans(Bool, Bool.and(v, List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, acc)), Bool.and(v, True{}), v, Equal.cong(Bool, Bool, k => Bool.and(v, k), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, acc), True{}, e), MBool.and_true(v))) case h <> t False{}: internal_all_reverse_go(~a, ~A, ~f, t, h <> acc, False{}, Equal.trans(Bool, Bool.and(f(h), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, acc)), Bool.and(f(h), False{}), False{}, Equal.cong(Bool, Bool, k => Bool.and(f(h), k), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, acc), False{}, e), MBool.and_false(f(h)))) # Reversing does not change whether all elements satisfy a predicate. law all_reverse: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List {List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) == List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, xs) : Bool} def all_reverse(a, A, f, xs): internal_all_reverse_go(~a, ~A, ~f, xs, Nil{}, True{}, {==}) def internal_any_reverse_go(~a: Quant, ~A: Kind(a), ~f: A -> Bool, xs: List, -acc: List, c: Bool, e: {List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, acc) == c : Bool}) -> {List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, acc)) == Bool.or(c, List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, xs)) : Bool}: match xs c: case Nil{} True{}: e case Nil{} False{}: e case h <> t True{}: internal_any_reverse_go(~a, ~A, ~f, t, h <> acc, True{}, Equal.trans(Bool, Bool.or(f(h), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, acc)), Bool.or(f(h), True{}), True{}, Equal.cong(Bool, Bool, k => Bool.or(f(h), k), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, acc), True{}, e), MBool.or_true(f(h)))) case h <> t False{}: +v = f(h) internal_any_reverse_go(~a, ~A, ~f, t, h <> acc, v, Equal.trans(Bool, Bool.or(v, List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, acc)), Bool.or(v, False{}), v, Equal.cong(Bool, Bool, k => Bool.or(v, k), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, acc), False{}, e), MBool.or_false(v))) # Reversing does not change whether some element satisfies a predicate. law any_reverse: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List {List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) == List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, xs) : Bool} def any_reverse(a, A, f, xs): internal_any_reverse_go(~a, ~A, ~f, xs, Nil{}, False{}, {==}) def internal_contains_reverse_go(~A: Data, ~eq: A -> A -> Bool, xs: List<&2, A>, -acc: List<&2, A>, +x: A, c: Bool, e: {List.contains(~A, ~eq, acc, x) == c : Bool}) -> {List.contains(~A, ~eq, List.reverse.go(&2, A, xs, acc), x) == Bool.or(c, List.contains(~A, ~eq, xs, x)) : Bool}: match xs c: case Nil{} True{}: e case Nil{} False{}: e case h <> t True{}: internal_contains_reverse_go(~A, ~eq, t, h <> acc, x, True{}, Equal.trans(Bool, Bool.or(eq(h, x), List.contains(~A, ~eq, acc, x)), Bool.or(eq(h, x), True{}), True{}, Equal.cong(Bool, Bool, k => Bool.or(eq(h, x), k), List.contains(~A, ~eq, acc, x), True{}, e), MBool.or_true(eq(h, x)))) case h <> t False{}: +v = eq(h, x) internal_contains_reverse_go(~A, ~eq, t, h <> acc, x, v, Equal.trans(Bool, Bool.or(v, List.contains(~A, ~eq, acc, x)), Bool.or(v, False{}), v, Equal.cong(Bool, Bool, k => Bool.or(v, k), List.contains(~A, ~eq, acc, x), False{}, e), MBool.or_false(v))) # Reversing does not change whether a list contains x. law contains_reverse: for ~A: Data for ~eq: A -> A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> for +x: A {List.contains(~A, ~eq, List.reverse(&2, A, xs), x) == List.contains(~A, ~eq, xs, x) : Bool} def contains_reverse(A, eq, xs, x): internal_contains_reverse_go(~A, ~eq, xs, Nil{}, x, False{}, {==}) # Zipping the empty list with anything gives the empty list. law zip_nil_left: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -b: Quant for -B: Kind(b) for -ys: List {List.zip(a, A, b, B, Nil{}, ys) == Nil{} : List<&1, A & B>} def zip_nil_left(a, A, b, B, ys): {==} # Zipping anything with the empty list gives the empty list. law zip_nil_right: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -b: Quant for -B: Kind(b) for xs: List {List.zip(a, A, b, B, xs, Nil{}) == Nil{} : List<&1, A & B>} def zip_nil_right(a, A, b, B, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: {==} # The head of a cons is its first element. law head_cons: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List {List.head(a, A, x <> xs) == Some{x} : Maybe} def head_cons(a, A, x, xs): {==} # The head of an append is the head of the first part, or else of the second. law head_append: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List {List.head(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) == Maybe.or(a, A, List.head(a, A, xs), List.head(a, A, ys)) : Maybe} def head_append(a, A, xs, ys): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: {==} # The head of a map is the mapped head. law head_map: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List {List.head(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) == Maybe.map(&1, A, B, f, List.head(&1, A, xs)) : Maybe<&1, B>} def head_map(A, B, f, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: {==} # The tail of a map is the map of the tail. law tail_map: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List {List.tail(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) == List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.tail(&1, A, xs)) : List} def tail_map(A, B, f, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: {==} # The element at index zero of a cons is its head. law get_cons_zero: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List {List.get(a, A, x <> xs, 0n) == Some{x} : Maybe} def get_cons_zero(a, A, x, xs): {==} # The element at index n + 1 of a cons is the element at index n of its tail. law get_cons_succ: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List for -n: Nat {List.get(a, A, x <> xs, 1n+n) == List.get(a, A, xs, n) : Maybe} def get_cons_succ(a, A, x, xs, n): {==} # Indexing a map is mapping the indexed element. law get_map: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List for n: Nat {List.get(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), n) == Maybe.map(&1, A, B, f, List.get(&1, A, xs, n)) : Maybe<&1, B>} def get_map(A, B, f, xs, n): match xs n: case Nil{} _: {==} case h <> t 0n: {==} case h <> t 1n+p: get_map(~A, ~B, ~f, t, p) # Setting an element does not change the length. law length_set: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat for -x: A {List.length(a, A, List.set(a, A, xs, n, x)) == List.length(a, A, xs) : Nat} def length_set(a, A, xs, n, x): match xs n: case Nil{} _: {==} case h <> t 0n: {==} case h <> t 1n+p: %length_set(a, A, t, p, x) : {1n+List.length(a, A, List.set(a, A, t, p, x)) == 1n+_ : Nat} {==} # Reading the index just set gives the new value wherever the index is in range. law get_set_self: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat for -x: A {List.get(a, A, List.set(a, A, xs, n, x), n) == Maybe.map(a, A, A, y => x, List.get(a, A, xs, n)) : Maybe} def get_set_self(a, A, xs, n, x): match xs n: case Nil{} _: {==} case h <> t 0n: {==} case h <> t 1n+p: get_set_self(a, A, t, p, x) def internal_last_go_append_singleton(a, -A: Kind(a), ys: List, -h: A, -x: A) -> {List.last.go(a, A, List.append(a, A, ys, [x]), h) == x : A}: match ys: case Nil{}: {==} case y <> t: internal_last_go_append_singleton(a, A, t, y, x) # The last element of xs ++ [x] is x. law last_append_singleton: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -x: A {List.last(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, [x])) == Some{x} : Maybe} def last_append_singleton(a, A, xs, x): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %internal_last_go_append_singleton(a, A, t, h, x) : {Some{List.last.go(a, A, List.append(a, A, t, [x]), h)} == Some{_} : Maybe} {==} def internal_head_reverse_go(a, -A: Kind(a), xs: List, -h: A, -acc: List) -> {List.head(a, A, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, h <> acc)) == Some{List.last.go(a, A, xs, h)} : Maybe}: match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case y <> t: internal_head_reverse_go(a, A, t, y, h <> acc) # The head of the reverse is the last element. law head_reverse: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.head(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) == List.last(a, A, xs) : Maybe} def head_reverse(a, A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: internal_head_reverse_go(a, A, t, h, Nil{}) def internal_last_reverse_go(a, -A: Kind(a), xs: List, -h: A, -acc: List) -> {List.last(a, A, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, h <> acc)) == Some{List.last.go(a, A, acc, h)} : Maybe}: match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case y <> t: internal_last_reverse_go(a, A, t, y, h <> acc) # The last element of the reverse is the head. law last_reverse: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.last(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) == List.head(a, A, xs) : Maybe} def last_reverse(a, A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: internal_last_reverse_go(a, A, t, h, Nil{}) # A list is empty exactly when its length is zero. law is_empty_iff_length_eq_zero: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.is_empty(a, A, xs) == Nat.is_eq(List.length(a, A, xs), 0n) : Bool} def is_empty_iff_length_eq_zero(a, A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: {==} # An append is empty exactly when both parts are. law is_empty_append: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List {List.is_empty(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) == Bool.and(List.is_empty(a, A, xs), List.is_empty(a, A, ys)) : Bool} def is_empty_append(a, A, xs, ys): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: {==} def internal_is_empty_reverse_go(a, -A: Kind(a), xs: List, -h: A, -acc: List) -> {List.is_empty(a, A, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, h <> acc)) == False{} : Bool}: match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case y <> t: internal_is_empty_reverse_go(a, A, t, y, h <> acc) # The reverse is empty exactly when the list is. law is_empty_reverse: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.is_empty(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) == List.is_empty(a, A, xs) : Bool} def is_empty_reverse(a, A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: internal_is_empty_reverse_go(a, A, t, h, Nil{}) # A map is empty exactly when the list is. law is_empty_map: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List {List.is_empty(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) == List.is_empty(&1, A, xs) : Bool} def is_empty_map(A, B, f, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: {==} def internal_reverse_filter_put(-A: Data, -h: A, r: List<&2, A>, b: Bool) -> {List.append(&2, A, List.reverse(&2, A, r), List.filter.put(A, h, Nil{}, b)) == List.reverse(&2, A, List.filter.put(A, h, r, b)) : List<&2, A>}: match b: case False{}: append_nil(&2, A, List.reverse(&2, A, r)) case True{}: Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.reverse.go(&2, A, r, [h]), List.append(&2, A, List.reverse(&2, A, r), [h]), reverse_go_spec(&2, A, r, [h])) # Filtering commutes with reversing: filter p (reverse xs) = reverse (filter p xs). law filter_reverse: for ~A: Data for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> {List.filter(~A, ~f, List.reverse(&2, A, xs)) == List.reverse(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, xs)) : List<&2, A>} def filter_reverse(A, f, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case +h <> t: +t = t %Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.reverse.go(&2, A, t, [h]), List.append(&2, A, List.reverse(&2, A, t), [h]), reverse_go_spec(&2, A, t, [h])) : {List.filter(~A, ~f, _) == List.reverse(&2, A, List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~f, t), f(h))) : List<&2, A>} %Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.filter(~A, ~f, List.append(&2, A, List.reverse(&2, A, t), [h])), List.append(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, List.reverse(&2, A, t)), List.filter(~A, ~f, [h])), filter_append(~A, ~f, List.reverse(&2, A, t), [h])) : {_ == List.reverse(&2, A, List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~f, t), f(h))) : List<&2, A>} %Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.filter(~A, ~f, List.reverse(&2, A, t)), List.reverse(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, t)), filter_reverse(~A, ~f, t)) : {List.append(&2, A, _, List.filter(~A, ~f, [h])) == List.reverse(&2, A, List.filter.put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~f, t), f(h))) : List<&2, A>} internal_reverse_filter_put(A, h, List.filter(~A, ~f, t), f(h)) # Folding cons from the right, starting from the empty list, rebuilds the list. law foldr_cons_nil: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~List, ~(x => acc => x <> acc), xs, Nil{}) == xs : List} def foldr_cons_nil(a, A, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %foldr_cons_nil(~a, ~A, t) : {h <> List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~List, ~(x => acc => x <> acc), t, Nil{}) == h <> _ : List} {==} def internal_foldl_reverse_go(~a: Quant, ~A: Kind(a), ~B: Type, ~f: B -> A -> B, xs: List, -acc: List, -z: B) -> {List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, acc), z) == List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, acc, List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~(x => y => f(y, x)), xs, z)) : B}: match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: internal_foldl_reverse_go(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, t, h <> acc, z) # A left fold over the reverse is a right fold with the arguments flipped. law foldl_reverse: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~B: Type for ~f: B -> A -> B for xs: List for -z: B {List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs), z) == List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~(x => y => f(y, x)), xs, z) : B} def foldl_reverse(a, A, B, f, xs, z): internal_foldl_reverse_go(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, Nil{}, z) def internal_foldr_reverse_go(~a: Quant, ~A: Kind(a), ~B: Type, ~f: A -> B -> B, xs: List, -acc: List, -z: B) -> {List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, acc), z) == List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~(x => y => f(y, x)), xs, List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, acc, z)) : B}: match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: internal_foldr_reverse_go(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, t, h <> acc, z) # A right fold over the reverse is a left fold with the arguments flipped. law foldr_reverse: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B -> B for xs: List for -z: B {List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs), z) == List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~(x => y => f(y, x)), xs, z) : B} def foldr_reverse(a, A, B, f, xs, z): internal_foldr_reverse_go(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, Nil{}, z) def internal_range_go_append(+n: Nat, -ys: List<&2, Nat>, -acc: List<&2, Nat>) -> {List.range.go(n, List.append(&2, Nat, ys, acc)) == List.append(&2, Nat, List.range.go(n, ys), acc) : List<&2, Nat>}: match n: case 0n: {==} case 1n+p: internal_range_go_append(p, p <> ys, acc) # Range(n + 1) is range(n) followed by n. law range_succ: for n: Nat {List.range(1n+n) == List.append(&2, Nat, List.range(n), [n]) : List<&2, Nat>} def range_succ(n): +n = n internal_range_go_append(n, Nil{}, [n]) def internal_find_put_or(-A: Data, h: A, r: Maybe<&2, A>, -s: Maybe<&2, A>, b: Bool) -> {Maybe.or(&2, A, List.find.put(A, h, r, b), s) == List.find.put(A, h, Maybe.or(&2, A, r, s), b) : Maybe<&2, A>}: match b: case False{}: {==} case True{}: {==} # Finding in an append finds in the first part, or else in the second. law find_append: for ~A: Data for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> for ys: List<&2, A> {List.find(~A, ~f, List.append(&2, A, xs, ys)) == Maybe.or(&2, A, List.find(~A, ~f, xs), List.find(~A, ~f, ys)) : Maybe<&2, A>} def find_append(A, f, xs, ys): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case +h <> t: +ys = ys +t = t %Equal.sym(Maybe<&2, A>, List.find(~A, ~f, List.append(&2, A, t, ys)), Maybe.or(&2, A, List.find(~A, ~f, t), List.find(~A, ~f, ys)), find_append(~A, ~f, t, ys)) : {List.find.put(A, h, _, f(h)) == Maybe.or(&2, A, List.find.put(A, h, List.find(~A, ~f, t), f(h)), List.find(~A, ~f, ys)) : Maybe<&2, A>} Equal.sym(Maybe<&2, A>, Maybe.or(&2, A, List.find.put(A, h, List.find(~A, ~f, t), f(h)), List.find(~A, ~f, ys)), List.find.put(A, h, Maybe.or(&2, A, List.find(~A, ~f, t), List.find(~A, ~f, ys)), f(h)), internal_find_put_or(A, h, List.find(~A, ~f, t), List.find(~A, ~f, ys), f(h))) def internal_and_not_eq_not_or_not(b: Bool, -s: Bool) -> {Bool.and(b, Bool.not(s)) == Bool.not(Bool.or(Bool.not(b), s)) : Bool}: match b: case False{}: {==} case True{}: {==} # All elements satisfy f exactly when no element fails it. law all_eq_not_any_not: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List {List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, xs) == Bool.not(List.any(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), xs)) : Bool} def all_eq_not_any_not(a, A, f, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %Equal.sym(Bool, List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, t), Bool.not(List.any(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), t)), all_eq_not_any_not(~a, ~A, ~f, t)) : {Bool.and(f(h), _) == Bool.not(Bool.or(Bool.not(f(h)), List.any(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), t))) : Bool} internal_and_not_eq_not_or_not(f(h), List.any(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), t)) def internal_or_not_eq_not_and_not(b: Bool, -s: Bool) -> {Bool.or(b, Bool.not(s)) == Bool.not(Bool.and(Bool.not(b), s)) : Bool}: match b: case False{}: {==} case True{}: {==} # Some element satisfies f exactly when not all elements fail it. law any_eq_not_all_not: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List {List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, xs) == Bool.not(List.all(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), xs)) : Bool} def any_eq_not_all_not(a, A, f, xs): match xs: case Nil{}: {==} case h <> t: %Equal.sym(Bool, List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, t), Bool.not(List.all(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), t)), any_eq_not_all_not(~a, ~A, ~f, t)) : {Bool.or(f(h), _) == Bool.not(Bool.and(Bool.not(f(h)), List.all(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), t))) : Bool} internal_or_not_eq_not_and_not(f(h), List.all(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), t)) # A one-element list has length one. law length_singleton: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A {List.length(a, A, [x]) == 1n : Nat} def length_singleton(a, A, x): {==} # Reversing a cons puts its head last: reverse (x :: xs) = reverse xs ++ [x]. law reverse_cons: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for xs: List {List.reverse(a, A, x <> xs) == List.append(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs), [x]) : List} def reverse_cons(a, A, x, xs): reverse_go_spec(a, A, xs, [x]) # Taking n + 1 elements of a cons keeps its head and takes n from its tail. law take_succ: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List for -n: Nat {List.take(a, A, x <> xs, 1n+n) == x <> List.take(a, A, xs, n) : List} def take_succ(a, A, x, xs, n): {==} # Dropping n + 1 elements of a cons drops its head and n from its tail. law drop_succ: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List for -n: Nat {List.drop(a, A, x <> xs, 1n+n) == List.drop(a, A, xs, n) : List} def drop_succ(a, A, x, xs, n): {==} # --- generated: _sym twins (tools/mathlib/twins.ts), do not edit --- # The empty list is a right identity for append: xs ++ [] = xs, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law append_nil_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {xs == List.append(a, A, xs, Nil{}) : List} def append_nil_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(List, List.append(a, A, xs, Nil{}), xs, append_nil(a, A, xs)) # The empty list is a left identity for append: [] ++ xs = xs, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law nil_append_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -xs: List {xs == List.append(a, A, Nil{}, xs) : List} def nil_append_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(List, List.append(a, A, Nil{}, xs), xs, nil_append(a, A, xs)) # Append is associative: (xs ++ ys) ++ zs = xs ++ (ys ++ zs), reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law append_assoc_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List for -zs: List {List.append(a, A, xs, List.append(a, A, ys, zs)) == List.append(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), zs) : List} def append_assoc_sym(a, A, xs, ys, zs): Equal.sym(List, List.append(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), zs), List.append(a, A, xs, List.append(a, A, ys, zs)), append_assoc(a, A, xs, ys, zs)) # The length of an append is the sum of the lengths, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_append_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List {Nat.add(List.length(a, A, xs), List.length(a, A, ys)) == List.length(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) : Nat} def length_append_sym(a, A, xs, ys): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)), Nat.add(List.length(a, A, xs), List.length(a, A, ys)), length_append(a, A, xs, ys)) # The reverse accumulator loop appends the reversed list to the accumulator, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law reverse_go_spec_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -acc: List {List.append(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs), acc) == List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, acc) : List} def reverse_go_spec_sym(a, A, xs, acc): Equal.sym(List, List.reverse.go(a, A, xs, acc), List.append(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs), acc), reverse_go_spec(a, A, xs, acc)) # Reversing an append reverses and swaps the parts: reverse (xs ++ ys) = reverse ys ++ reverse xs, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law reverse_append_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List {List.append(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, ys), List.reverse(a, A, xs)) == List.reverse(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) : List} def reverse_append_sym(a, A, xs, ys): Equal.sym(List, List.reverse(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)), List.append(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, ys), List.reverse(a, A, xs)), reverse_append(a, A, xs, ys)) # Reversing twice gives the list back, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law reverse_reverse_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {xs == List.reverse(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) : List} def reverse_reverse_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(List, List.reverse(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)), xs, reverse_reverse(a, A, xs)) # Reversing preserves the length, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_reverse_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.length(a, A, xs) == List.length(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) : Nat} def length_reverse_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)), List.length(a, A, xs), length_reverse(a, A, xs)) # A right fold over an append folds the first part onto the fold of the second, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law foldr_append_sym: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B -> B for xs: List for -ys: List for -z: B {List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, ys, z)) == List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), z) : B} def foldr_append_sym(a, A, B, f, xs, ys, z): Equal.sym(B, List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), z), List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, ys, z)), foldr_append(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, ys, z)) # Taking n elements and appending the rest after dropping n gives the list back, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law take_append_drop_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat {xs == List.append(a, A, List.take(a, A, xs, n), List.drop(a, A, xs, n)) : List} def take_append_drop_sym(a, A, xs, n): Equal.sym(List, List.append(a, A, List.take(a, A, xs, n), List.drop(a, A, xs, n)), xs, take_append_drop(a, A, xs, n)) # Mapping preserves the length, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_map_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List {List.length(&1, A, xs) == List.length(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) : Nat} def length_map_sym(A, B, f, xs): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)), List.length(&1, A, xs), length_map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) # Mapping over an append maps each part: map f (xs ++ ys) = map f xs ++ map f ys, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law map_append_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List for -ys: List {List.append(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, ys)) == List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.append(&1, A, xs, ys)) : List} def map_append_sym(A, B, f, xs, ys): Equal.sym(List, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.append(&1, A, xs, ys)), List.append(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, ys)), map_append(~A, ~B, ~f, xs, ys)) # Mapping twice is mapping the composition: map g (map f xs) = map (g . f) xs, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law map_map_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~C: Type for ~f: A -> B for ~g: B -> C for xs: List {List.map(~A, ~C, ~(x => g(f(x))), xs) == List.map(~B, ~C, ~g, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) : List} def map_map_sym(A, B, C, f, g, xs): Equal.sym(List, List.map(~B, ~C, ~g, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)), List.map(~A, ~C, ~(x => g(f(x))), xs), map_map(~A, ~B, ~C, ~f, ~g, xs)) # Taking zero elements gives the empty list, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law take_zero_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {Nil{} == List.take(a, A, xs, 0n) : List} def take_zero_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(List, List.take(a, A, xs, 0n), Nil{}, take_zero(a, A, xs)) # Dropping zero elements gives the list back, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law drop_zero_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {xs == List.drop(a, A, xs, 0n) : List} def drop_zero_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(List, List.drop(a, A, xs, 0n), xs, drop_zero(a, A, xs)) # Taking from the empty list gives the empty list, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law take_nil_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -n: Nat {Nil{} == List.take(a, A, Nil{}, n) : List} def take_nil_sym(a, A, n): Equal.sym(List, List.take(a, A, Nil{}, n), Nil{}, take_nil(a, A, n)) # Dropping from the empty list gives the empty list, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law drop_nil_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -n: Nat {Nil{} == List.drop(a, A, Nil{}, n) : List} def drop_nil_sym(a, A, n): Equal.sym(List, List.drop(a, A, Nil{}, n), Nil{}, drop_nil(a, A, n)) # Taking n elements leaves min(n, length) of them, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_take_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat {Nat.min(n, List.length(a, A, xs)) == List.length(a, A, List.take(a, A, xs, n)) : Nat} def length_take_sym(a, A, xs, n): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(a, A, List.take(a, A, xs, n)), Nat.min(n, List.length(a, A, xs)), length_take(a, A, xs, n)) # Dropping n elements leaves length - n of them, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_drop_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat {Nat.sub(List.length(a, A, xs), n) == List.length(a, A, List.drop(a, A, xs, n)) : Nat} def length_drop_sym(a, A, xs, n): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(a, A, List.drop(a, A, xs, n)), Nat.sub(List.length(a, A, xs), n), length_drop(a, A, xs, n)) # Taking as many elements as the list has gives the list back, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law take_length_sym: for -A: Data for +xs: List<&2, A> {xs == List.take(&2, A, xs, List.length(&2, A, xs)) : List<&2, A>} def take_length_sym(A, xs): Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.take(&2, A, xs, List.length(&2, A, xs)), xs, take_length(A, xs)) # Dropping as many elements as the list has gives the empty list, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law drop_length_sym: for -A: Data for +xs: List<&2, A> {Nil{} == List.drop(&2, A, xs, List.length(&2, A, xs)) : List<&2, A>} def drop_length_sym(A, xs): Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.drop(&2, A, xs, List.length(&2, A, xs)), Nil{}, drop_length(A, xs)) # Taking m from the first n is taking min(n, m), reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law take_take_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat for m: Nat {List.take(a, A, xs, Nat.min(n, m)) == List.take(a, A, List.take(a, A, xs, n), m) : List} def take_take_sym(a, A, xs, n, m): Equal.sym(List, List.take(a, A, List.take(a, A, xs, n), m), List.take(a, A, xs, Nat.min(n, m)), take_take(a, A, xs, n, m)) # Dropping m after dropping n is dropping n + m, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law drop_drop_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat for -m: Nat {List.drop(a, A, xs, Nat.add(n, m)) == List.drop(a, A, List.drop(a, A, xs, n), m) : List} def drop_drop_sym(a, A, xs, n, m): Equal.sym(List, List.drop(a, A, List.drop(a, A, xs, n), m), List.drop(a, A, xs, Nat.add(n, m)), drop_drop(a, A, xs, n, m)) # Reversing the empty list gives the empty list, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law reverse_nil_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) {Nil{} == List.reverse(a, A, Nil{}) : List} def reverse_nil_sym(a, A): Equal.sym(List, List.reverse(a, A, Nil{}), Nil{}, reverse_nil(a, A)) # Reversing a one-element list gives it back, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law reverse_singleton_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A {[x] == List.reverse(a, A, [x]) : List} def reverse_singleton_sym(a, A, x): Equal.sym(List, List.reverse(a, A, [x]), [x], reverse_singleton(a, A, x)) # Replicating x n times gives a list of length n, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_replicate_sym: for -A: Data for n: Nat for -x: A {n == List.length(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x)) : Nat} def length_replicate_sym(A, n, x): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x)), n, length_replicate(A, n, x)) # Range(n) has length n, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_range_sym: for n: Nat {n == List.length(&2, Nat, List.range(n)) : Nat} def length_range_sym(n): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(&2, Nat, List.range(n)), n, length_range(n)) # Zipping two lists gives the length of the shorter one, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_zip_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List {Nat.min(List.length(a, A, xs), List.length(a, A, ys)) == List.length(&1, A & A, List.zip(a, A, a, A, xs, ys)) : Nat} def length_zip_sym(a, A, xs, ys): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(&1, A & A, List.zip(a, A, a, A, xs, ys)), Nat.min(List.length(a, A, xs), List.length(a, A, ys)), length_zip(a, A, xs, ys)) # Appending after a cons: (x :: xs) ++ ys = x :: (xs ++ ys), reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law append_cons_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List for -ys: List {x <> List.append(a, A, xs, ys) == List.append(a, A, x <> xs, ys) : List} def append_cons_sym(a, A, x, xs, ys): Equal.sym(List, List.append(a, A, x <> xs, ys), x <> List.append(a, A, xs, ys), append_cons(a, A, x, xs, ys)) # The empty list has length zero, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_nil_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) {0n == List.length(a, A, Nil{}) : Nat} def length_nil_sym(a, A): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(a, A, Nil{}), 0n, length_nil(a, A)) # A cons is one longer than its tail, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_cons_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List {1n+List.length(a, A, xs) == List.length(a, A, x <> xs) : Nat} def length_cons_sym(a, A, x, xs): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(a, A, x <> xs), 1n+List.length(a, A, xs), length_cons(a, A, x, xs)) # Concatenating an append concatenates each part: concat (xss ++ yss) = concat xss ++ concat yss, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law concat_append_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xss: List> for -yss: List> {List.append(a, A, List.concat(a, A, xss), List.concat(a, A, yss)) == List.concat(a, A, List.append(a, List, xss, yss)) : List} def concat_append_sym(a, A, xss, yss): Equal.sym(List, List.concat(a, A, List.append(a, List, xss, yss)), List.append(a, A, List.concat(a, A, xss), List.concat(a, A, yss)), concat_append(a, A, xss, yss)) # A left fold over an append folds the second part from the fold of the first, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law foldl_append_sym: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~B: Type for ~f: B -> A -> B for xs: List for -ys: List for -z: B {List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, ys, List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, z)) == List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), z) : B} def foldl_append_sym(a, A, B, f, xs, ys, z): Equal.sym(B, List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), z), List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, ys, List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, z)), foldl_append(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, ys, z)) # Mapping commutes with reversing: map f (reverse xs) = reverse (map f xs), reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law map_reverse_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List {List.reverse(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) == List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse(&1, A, xs)) : List} def map_reverse_sym(A, B, f, xs): Equal.sym(List, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse(&1, A, xs)), List.reverse(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)), map_reverse(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) # All over an append is all over each part, joined by and, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law all_append_sym: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List for -ys: List {Bool.and(List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, xs), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)) == List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) : Bool} def all_append_sym(a, A, f, xs, ys): Equal.sym(Bool, List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)), Bool.and(List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, xs), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)), all_append(~a, ~A, ~f, xs, ys)) # Any over an append is any over each part, joined by or, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law any_append_sym: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List for -ys: List {Bool.or(List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, xs), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)) == List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) : Bool} def any_append_sym(a, A, f, xs, ys): Equal.sym(Bool, List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)), Bool.or(List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, xs), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, ys)), any_append(~a, ~A, ~f, xs, ys)) # Filtering an append filters each part, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law filter_append_sym: for ~A: Data for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> for ys: List<&2, A> {List.append(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, xs), List.filter(~A, ~f, ys)) == List.filter(~A, ~f, List.append(&2, A, xs, ys)) : List<&2, A>} def filter_append_sym(A, f, xs, ys): Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.filter(~A, ~f, List.append(&2, A, xs, ys)), List.append(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, xs), List.filter(~A, ~f, ys)), filter_append(~A, ~f, xs, ys)) # An append contains x iff either part does, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law contains_append_sym: for ~A: Data for ~eq: A -> A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> for -ys: List<&2, A> for +x: A {Bool.or(List.contains(~A, ~eq, xs, x), List.contains(~A, ~eq, ys, x)) == List.contains(~A, ~eq, List.append(&2, A, xs, ys), x) : Bool} def contains_append_sym(A, eq, xs, ys, x): Equal.sym(Bool, List.contains(~A, ~eq, List.append(&2, A, xs, ys), x), Bool.or(List.contains(~A, ~eq, xs, x), List.contains(~A, ~eq, ys, x)), contains_append(~A, ~eq, xs, ys, x)) # Filtering never makes a list longer, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_filter_le_sym: for ~A: Data for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> {True{} == Nat.is_le(List.length(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, xs)), List.length(&2, A, xs)) : Bool} def length_filter_le_sym(A, f, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, Nat.is_le(List.length(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, xs)), List.length(&2, A, xs)), True{}, length_filter_le(~A, ~f, xs)) # Taking the length of the first part of an append gives the first part back, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law take_left_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List {xs == List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), List.length(a, A, xs)) : List} def take_left_sym(a, A, xs, ys): Equal.sym(List, List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), List.length(a, A, xs)), xs, take_left(a, A, xs, ys)) # Dropping the length of the first part of an append gives the second part, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law drop_left_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List {ys == List.drop(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), List.length(a, A, xs)) : List} def drop_left_sym(a, A, xs, ys): Equal.sym(List, List.drop(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), List.length(a, A, xs)), ys, drop_left(a, A, xs, ys)) # Taking past the first part of an append keeps it and takes the rest from the second part, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law take_append_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List for -n: Nat {List.append(a, A, xs, List.take(a, A, ys, n)) == List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), Nat.add(List.length(a, A, xs), n)) : List} def take_append_sym(a, A, xs, ys, n): Equal.sym(List, List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), Nat.add(List.length(a, A, xs), n)), List.append(a, A, xs, List.take(a, A, ys, n)), take_append(a, A, xs, ys, n)) # Dropping past the first part of an append drops the rest from the second part, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law drop_append_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List for -n: Nat {List.drop(a, A, ys, n) == List.drop(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), Nat.add(List.length(a, A, xs), n)) : List} def drop_append_sym(a, A, xs, ys, n): Equal.sym(List, List.drop(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), Nat.add(List.length(a, A, xs), n)), List.drop(a, A, ys, n), drop_append(a, A, xs, ys, n)) # Taking at most the length of the first part of an append only sees the first part, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law take_append_of_le_length_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List for n: Nat for h: MNat.le(n, List.length(a, A, xs)) {List.take(a, A, xs, n) == List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), n) : List} def take_append_of_le_length_sym(a, A, xs, ys, n, h): Equal.sym(List, List.take(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), n), List.take(a, A, xs, n), take_append_of_le_length(a, A, xs, ys, n, h)) # Dropping at most the length of the first part of an append drops only from the first part, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law drop_append_of_le_length_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for ys: List for n: Nat for h: MNat.le(n, List.length(a, A, xs)) {List.append(a, A, List.drop(a, A, xs, n), ys) == List.drop(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), n) : List} def drop_append_of_le_length_sym(a, A, xs, ys, n, h): Equal.sym(List, List.drop(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys), n), List.append(a, A, List.drop(a, A, xs, n), ys), drop_append_of_le_length(a, A, xs, ys, n, h)) # Mapping commutes with taking: map f (take n xs) = take n (map f xs), reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law map_take_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List for n: Nat {List.take(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), n) == List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.take(&1, A, xs, n)) : List} def map_take_sym(A, B, f, xs, n): Equal.sym(List, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.take(&1, A, xs, n)), List.take(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), n), map_take(~A, ~B, ~f, xs, n)) # Mapping commutes with dropping: map f (drop n xs) = drop n (map f xs), reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law map_drop_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List for n: Nat {List.drop(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), n) == List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.drop(&1, A, xs, n)) : List} def map_drop_sym(A, B, f, xs, n): Equal.sym(List, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.drop(&1, A, xs, n)), List.drop(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), n), map_drop(~A, ~B, ~f, xs, n)) # Taking m from n copies of x gives min(m, n) copies of x, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law take_replicate_sym: for -A: Data for n: Nat for m: Nat for -x: A {List.replicate(A, Nat.min(m, n), x) == List.take(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), m) : List<&2, A>} def take_replicate_sym(A, n, m, x): Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.take(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), m), List.replicate(A, Nat.min(m, n), x), take_replicate(A, n, m, x)) # Dropping m from n copies of x gives n - m copies of x, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law drop_replicate_sym: for -A: Data for n: Nat for m: Nat for -x: A {List.replicate(A, Nat.sub(n, m), x) == List.drop(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), m) : List<&2, A>} def drop_replicate_sym(A, n, m, x): Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.drop(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x), m), List.replicate(A, Nat.sub(n, m), x), drop_replicate(A, n, m, x)) # The tail is one shorter than the list, or empty: length (tail xs) = length xs - 1, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_tail_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {Nat.sub(List.length(a, A, xs), 1n) == List.length(a, A, List.tail(a, A, xs)) : Nat} def length_tail_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(a, A, List.tail(a, A, xs)), Nat.sub(List.length(a, A, xs), 1n), length_tail(a, A, xs)) # Mapping the identity gives the list back, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law map_id_sym: for ~A: Type for xs: List {xs == List.map(~A, ~A, ~(x => x), xs) : List} def map_id_sym(A, xs): Equal.sym(List, List.map(~A, ~A, ~(x => x), xs), xs, map_id(~A, xs)) # A right fold over a map folds with the mapped function: foldr g z (map f xs) = foldr (g . f) z xs, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law foldr_map_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~C: Type for ~f: A -> B for ~g: B -> C -> C for xs: List for -z: C {List.foldr(~&1, ~A, ~C, ~(x => y => g(f(x), y)), xs, z) == List.foldr(~&1, ~B, ~C, ~g, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), z) : C} def foldr_map_sym(A, B, C, f, g, xs, z): Equal.sym(C, List.foldr(~&1, ~B, ~C, ~g, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), z), List.foldr(~&1, ~A, ~C, ~(x => y => g(f(x), y)), xs, z), foldr_map(~A, ~B, ~C, ~f, ~g, xs, z)) # A left fold over a map folds with the mapped function: foldl g z (map f xs) = foldl (fun acc x => g acc (f x)) z xs, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law foldl_map_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~C: Type for ~f: A -> B for ~g: C -> B -> C for xs: List for -z: C {List.foldl(~&1, ~A, ~C, ~(x => y => g(x, f(y))), xs, z) == List.foldl(~&1, ~B, ~C, ~g, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), z) : C} def foldl_map_sym(A, B, C, f, g, xs, z): Equal.sym(C, List.foldl(~&1, ~B, ~C, ~g, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), z), List.foldl(~&1, ~A, ~C, ~(x => y => g(x, f(y))), xs, z), foldl_map(~A, ~B, ~C, ~f, ~g, xs, z)) # Replicating m + n times appends m copies to n copies, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law replicate_add_sym: for -A: Data for m: Nat for -n: Nat for -x: A {List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, m, x), List.replicate(A, n, x)) == List.replicate(A, Nat.add(m, n), x) : List<&2, A>} def replicate_add_sym(A, m, n, x): Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.replicate(A, Nat.add(m, n), x), List.append(&2, A, List.replicate(A, m, x), List.replicate(A, n, x)), replicate_add(A, m, n, x)) # Reversing n copies of x gives them back, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law reverse_replicate_sym: for -A: Data for n: Nat for -x: A {List.replicate(A, n, x) == List.reverse(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x)) : List<&2, A>} def reverse_replicate_sym(A, n, x): Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.reverse(&2, A, List.replicate(A, n, x)), List.replicate(A, n, x), reverse_replicate(A, n, x)) # Filtering with an always-true predicate gives the list back, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law filter_true_sym: for ~A: Data for xs: List<&2, A> {xs == List.filter(~A, ~(x => True{}), xs) : List<&2, A>} def filter_true_sym(A, xs): Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.filter(~A, ~(x => True{}), xs), xs, filter_true(~A, xs)) # Filtering with an always-false predicate gives the empty list, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law filter_false_sym: for ~A: Data for xs: List<&2, A> {Nil{} == List.filter(~A, ~(x => False{}), xs) : List<&2, A>} def filter_false_sym(A, xs): Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.filter(~A, ~(x => False{}), xs), Nil{}, filter_false(~A, xs)) # Filtering twice is filtering by both predicates: filter p (filter q xs) = filter (p and q) xs, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law filter_filter_sym: for ~A: Data for ~p: A -> Bool for ~q: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> {List.filter(~A, ~(+x => Bool.and(p(x), q(x))), xs) == List.filter(~A, ~p, List.filter(~A, ~q, xs)) : List<&2, A>} def filter_filter_sym(A, p, q, xs): Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.filter(~A, ~p, List.filter(~A, ~q, xs)), List.filter(~A, ~(+x => Bool.and(p(x), q(x))), xs), filter_filter(~A, ~p, ~q, xs)) # All over a filter checks q only where p holds: all q (filter p xs) = all (not p or q) xs, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law all_filter_sym: for ~A: Data for ~p: A -> Bool for ~q: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> {List.all(~&2, ~A, ~(+x => Bool.or(Bool.not(p(x)), q(x))), xs) == List.all(~&2, ~A, ~q, List.filter(~A, ~p, xs)) : Bool} def all_filter_sym(A, p, q, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, List.all(~&2, ~A, ~q, List.filter(~A, ~p, xs)), List.all(~&2, ~A, ~(+x => Bool.or(Bool.not(p(x)), q(x))), xs), all_filter(~A, ~p, ~q, xs)) # Any over a filter looks for q only where p holds: any q (filter p xs) = any (p and q) xs, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law any_filter_sym: for ~A: Data for ~p: A -> Bool for ~q: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> {List.any(~&2, ~A, ~(+x => Bool.and(p(x), q(x))), xs) == List.any(~&2, ~A, ~q, List.filter(~A, ~p, xs)) : Bool} def any_filter_sym(A, p, q, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, List.any(~&2, ~A, ~q, List.filter(~A, ~p, xs)), List.any(~&2, ~A, ~(+x => Bool.and(p(x), q(x))), xs), any_filter(~A, ~p, ~q, xs)) # All over a map checks the composed predicate: all p (map f xs) = all (p . f) xs, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law all_map_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for ~p: B -> Bool for xs: List {List.all(~&1, ~A, ~(x => p(f(x))), xs) == List.all(~&1, ~B, ~p, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) : Bool} def all_map_sym(A, B, f, p, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, List.all(~&1, ~B, ~p, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)), List.all(~&1, ~A, ~(x => p(f(x))), xs), all_map(~A, ~B, ~f, ~p, xs)) # Any over a map checks the composed predicate: any p (map f xs) = any (p . f) xs, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law any_map_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for ~p: B -> Bool for xs: List {List.any(~&1, ~A, ~(x => p(f(x))), xs) == List.any(~&1, ~B, ~p, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) : Bool} def any_map_sym(A, B, f, p, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, List.any(~&1, ~B, ~p, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)), List.any(~&1, ~A, ~(x => p(f(x))), xs), any_map(~A, ~B, ~f, ~p, xs)) # Reversing does not change whether all elements satisfy a predicate, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law all_reverse_sym: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List {List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, xs) == List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) : Bool} def all_reverse_sym(a, A, f, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs)), List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, xs), all_reverse(~a, ~A, ~f, xs)) # Reversing does not change whether some element satisfies a predicate, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law any_reverse_sym: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List {List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, xs) == List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) : Bool} def any_reverse_sym(a, A, f, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs)), List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, xs), any_reverse(~a, ~A, ~f, xs)) # Reversing does not change whether a list contains x, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law contains_reverse_sym: for ~A: Data for ~eq: A -> A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> for +x: A {List.contains(~A, ~eq, xs, x) == List.contains(~A, ~eq, List.reverse(&2, A, xs), x) : Bool} def contains_reverse_sym(A, eq, xs, x): Equal.sym(Bool, List.contains(~A, ~eq, List.reverse(&2, A, xs), x), List.contains(~A, ~eq, xs, x), contains_reverse(~A, ~eq, xs, x)) # Zipping the empty list with anything gives the empty list, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law zip_nil_left_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -b: Quant for -B: Kind(b) for -ys: List {Nil{} == List.zip(a, A, b, B, Nil{}, ys) : List<&1, A & B>} def zip_nil_left_sym(a, A, b, B, ys): Equal.sym(List<&1, A & B>, List.zip(a, A, b, B, Nil{}, ys), Nil{}, zip_nil_left(a, A, b, B, ys)) # Zipping anything with the empty list gives the empty list, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law zip_nil_right_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -b: Quant for -B: Kind(b) for xs: List {Nil{} == List.zip(a, A, b, B, xs, Nil{}) : List<&1, A & B>} def zip_nil_right_sym(a, A, b, B, xs): Equal.sym(List<&1, A & B>, List.zip(a, A, b, B, xs, Nil{}), Nil{}, zip_nil_right(a, A, b, B, xs)) # The head of a cons is its first element, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law head_cons_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List {Some{x} == List.head(a, A, x <> xs) : Maybe} def head_cons_sym(a, A, x, xs): Equal.sym(Maybe, List.head(a, A, x <> xs), Some{x}, head_cons(a, A, x, xs)) # The head of an append is the head of the first part, or else of the second, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law head_append_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List {Maybe.or(a, A, List.head(a, A, xs), List.head(a, A, ys)) == List.head(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) : Maybe} def head_append_sym(a, A, xs, ys): Equal.sym(Maybe, List.head(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)), Maybe.or(a, A, List.head(a, A, xs), List.head(a, A, ys)), head_append(a, A, xs, ys)) # The head of a map is the mapped head, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law head_map_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List {Maybe.map(&1, A, B, f, List.head(&1, A, xs)) == List.head(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) : Maybe<&1, B>} def head_map_sym(A, B, f, xs): Equal.sym(Maybe<&1, B>, List.head(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)), Maybe.map(&1, A, B, f, List.head(&1, A, xs)), head_map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) # The tail of a map is the map of the tail, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law tail_map_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List {List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.tail(&1, A, xs)) == List.tail(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) : List} def tail_map_sym(A, B, f, xs): Equal.sym(List, List.tail(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)), List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, List.tail(&1, A, xs)), tail_map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) # The element at index zero of a cons is its head, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law get_cons_zero_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List {Some{x} == List.get(a, A, x <> xs, 0n) : Maybe} def get_cons_zero_sym(a, A, x, xs): Equal.sym(Maybe, List.get(a, A, x <> xs, 0n), Some{x}, get_cons_zero(a, A, x, xs)) # The element at index n + 1 of a cons is the element at index n of its tail, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law get_cons_succ_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List for -n: Nat {List.get(a, A, xs, n) == List.get(a, A, x <> xs, 1n+n) : Maybe} def get_cons_succ_sym(a, A, x, xs, n): Equal.sym(Maybe, List.get(a, A, x <> xs, 1n+n), List.get(a, A, xs, n), get_cons_succ(a, A, x, xs, n)) # Indexing a map is mapping the indexed element, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law get_map_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List for n: Nat {Maybe.map(&1, A, B, f, List.get(&1, A, xs, n)) == List.get(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), n) : Maybe<&1, B>} def get_map_sym(A, B, f, xs, n): Equal.sym(Maybe<&1, B>, List.get(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs), n), Maybe.map(&1, A, B, f, List.get(&1, A, xs, n)), get_map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs, n)) # Setting an element does not change the length, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_set_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat for -x: A {List.length(a, A, xs) == List.length(a, A, List.set(a, A, xs, n, x)) : Nat} def length_set_sym(a, A, xs, n, x): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(a, A, List.set(a, A, xs, n, x)), List.length(a, A, xs), length_set(a, A, xs, n, x)) # Reading the index just set gives the new value wherever the index is in range, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law get_set_self_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for n: Nat for -x: A {Maybe.map(a, A, A, y => x, List.get(a, A, xs, n)) == List.get(a, A, List.set(a, A, xs, n, x), n) : Maybe} def get_set_self_sym(a, A, xs, n, x): Equal.sym(Maybe, List.get(a, A, List.set(a, A, xs, n, x), n), Maybe.map(a, A, A, y => x, List.get(a, A, xs, n)), get_set_self(a, A, xs, n, x)) # The last element of xs ++ [x] is x, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law last_append_singleton_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -x: A {Some{x} == List.last(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, [x])) : Maybe} def last_append_singleton_sym(a, A, xs, x): Equal.sym(Maybe, List.last(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, [x])), Some{x}, last_append_singleton(a, A, xs, x)) # The head of the reverse is the last element, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law head_reverse_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.last(a, A, xs) == List.head(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) : Maybe} def head_reverse_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(Maybe, List.head(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)), List.last(a, A, xs), head_reverse(a, A, xs)) # The last element of the reverse is the head, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law last_reverse_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.head(a, A, xs) == List.last(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) : Maybe} def last_reverse_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(Maybe, List.last(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)), List.head(a, A, xs), last_reverse(a, A, xs)) # A list is empty exactly when its length is zero, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law is_empty_iff_length_eq_zero_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {Nat.is_eq(List.length(a, A, xs), 0n) == List.is_empty(a, A, xs) : Bool} def is_empty_iff_length_eq_zero_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, List.is_empty(a, A, xs), Nat.is_eq(List.length(a, A, xs), 0n), is_empty_iff_length_eq_zero(a, A, xs)) # An append is empty exactly when both parts are, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law is_empty_append_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List for -ys: List {Bool.and(List.is_empty(a, A, xs), List.is_empty(a, A, ys)) == List.is_empty(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)) : Bool} def is_empty_append_sym(a, A, xs, ys): Equal.sym(Bool, List.is_empty(a, A, List.append(a, A, xs, ys)), Bool.and(List.is_empty(a, A, xs), List.is_empty(a, A, ys)), is_empty_append(a, A, xs, ys)) # The reverse is empty exactly when the list is, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law is_empty_reverse_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for xs: List {List.is_empty(a, A, xs) == List.is_empty(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)) : Bool} def is_empty_reverse_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, List.is_empty(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs)), List.is_empty(a, A, xs), is_empty_reverse(a, A, xs)) # A map is empty exactly when the list is, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law is_empty_map_sym: for ~A: Type for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B for xs: List {List.is_empty(&1, A, xs) == List.is_empty(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) : Bool} def is_empty_map_sym(A, B, f, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, List.is_empty(&1, B, List.map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)), List.is_empty(&1, A, xs), is_empty_map(~A, ~B, ~f, xs)) # Filtering commutes with reversing: filter p (reverse xs) = reverse (filter p xs), reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law filter_reverse_sym: for ~A: Data for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> {List.reverse(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, xs)) == List.filter(~A, ~f, List.reverse(&2, A, xs)) : List<&2, A>} def filter_reverse_sym(A, f, xs): Equal.sym(List<&2, A>, List.filter(~A, ~f, List.reverse(&2, A, xs)), List.reverse(&2, A, List.filter(~A, ~f, xs)), filter_reverse(~A, ~f, xs)) # Folding cons from the right, starting from the empty list, rebuilds the list, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law foldr_cons_nil_sym: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for xs: List {xs == List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~List, ~(x => acc => x <> acc), xs, Nil{}) : List} def foldr_cons_nil_sym(a, A, xs): Equal.sym(List, List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~List, ~(x => acc => x <> acc), xs, Nil{}), xs, foldr_cons_nil(~a, ~A, xs)) # A left fold over the reverse is a right fold with the arguments flipped, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law foldl_reverse_sym: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~B: Type for ~f: B -> A -> B for xs: List for -z: B {List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~(x => y => f(y, x)), xs, z) == List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs), z) : B} def foldl_reverse_sym(a, A, B, f, xs, z): Equal.sym(B, List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs), z), List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~(x => y => f(y, x)), xs, z), foldl_reverse(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, z)) # A right fold over the reverse is a left fold with the arguments flipped, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law foldr_reverse_sym: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~B: Type for ~f: A -> B -> B for xs: List for -z: B {List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~(x => y => f(y, x)), xs, z) == List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs), z) : B} def foldr_reverse_sym(a, A, B, f, xs, z): Equal.sym(B, List.foldr(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, List.reverse(a, A, xs), z), List.foldl(~a, ~A, ~B, ~(x => y => f(y, x)), xs, z), foldr_reverse(~a, ~A, ~B, ~f, xs, z)) # Range(n + 1) is range(n) followed by n, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law range_succ_sym: for n: Nat {List.append(&2, Nat, List.range(n), [n]) == List.range(1n+n) : List<&2, Nat>} def range_succ_sym(n): Equal.sym(List<&2, Nat>, List.range(1n+n), List.append(&2, Nat, List.range(n), [n]), range_succ(n)) # Finding in an append finds in the first part, or else in the second, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law find_append_sym: for ~A: Data for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List<&2, A> for ys: List<&2, A> {Maybe.or(&2, A, List.find(~A, ~f, xs), List.find(~A, ~f, ys)) == List.find(~A, ~f, List.append(&2, A, xs, ys)) : Maybe<&2, A>} def find_append_sym(A, f, xs, ys): Equal.sym(Maybe<&2, A>, List.find(~A, ~f, List.append(&2, A, xs, ys)), Maybe.or(&2, A, List.find(~A, ~f, xs), List.find(~A, ~f, ys)), find_append(~A, ~f, xs, ys)) # All elements satisfy f exactly when no element fails it, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law all_eq_not_any_not_sym: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List {Bool.not(List.any(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), xs)) == List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, xs) : Bool} def all_eq_not_any_not_sym(a, A, f, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, List.all(~a, ~A, ~f, xs), Bool.not(List.any(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), xs)), all_eq_not_any_not(~a, ~A, ~f, xs)) # Some element satisfies f exactly when not all elements fail it, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law any_eq_not_all_not_sym: for ~a: Quant for ~A: Kind(a) for ~f: A -> Bool for xs: List {Bool.not(List.all(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), xs)) == List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, xs) : Bool} def any_eq_not_all_not_sym(a, A, f, xs): Equal.sym(Bool, List.any(~a, ~A, ~f, xs), Bool.not(List.all(~a, ~A, ~(x => Bool.not(f(x))), xs)), any_eq_not_all_not(~a, ~A, ~f, xs)) # A one-element list has length one, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law length_singleton_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A {1n == List.length(a, A, [x]) : Nat} def length_singleton_sym(a, A, x): Equal.sym(Nat, List.length(a, A, [x]), 1n, length_singleton(a, A, x)) # Reversing a cons puts its head last: reverse (x :: xs) = reverse xs ++ [x], reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law reverse_cons_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for xs: List {List.append(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs), [x]) == List.reverse(a, A, x <> xs) : List} def reverse_cons_sym(a, A, x, xs): Equal.sym(List, List.reverse(a, A, x <> xs), List.append(a, A, List.reverse(a, A, xs), [x]), reverse_cons(a, A, x, xs)) # Taking n + 1 elements of a cons keeps its head and takes n from its tail, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law take_succ_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List for -n: Nat {x <> List.take(a, A, xs, n) == List.take(a, A, x <> xs, 1n+n) : List} def take_succ_sym(a, A, x, xs, n): Equal.sym(List, List.take(a, A, x <> xs, 1n+n), x <> List.take(a, A, xs, n), take_succ(a, A, x, xs, n)) # Dropping n + 1 elements of a cons drops its head and n from its tail, reversed to rewrite toward the simple side. law drop_succ_sym: for -a: Quant for -A: Kind(a) for -x: A for -xs: List for -n: Nat {List.drop(a, A, xs, n) == List.drop(a, A, x <> xs, 1n+n) : List} def drop_succ_sym(a, A, x, xs, n): Equal.sym(List, List.drop(a, A, x <> xs, 1n+n), List.drop(a, A, xs, n), drop_succ(a, A, x, xs, n))